European court to hear landmark case regarding discrimination against non-binary people

26.04.2024

The entrance of the Court of Justice of the EU

scroll

The Court of Justice of the European Union is to decide on lawsuit over the lack of provision of an option for non-binary persons, which may have a far-reaching effect

On Monday, April 29, the Court of Justice will be required to answer the question: Does GDPR and European non-discrimination law require organisations to provide an option for non-binary persons in their forms?

The hearing follows a lawsuit filed by the Mousse Association, representing 64 individuals, against France’s national state-owned railway company’s (SNCF) practice of forcing passengers to choose between the civil titles “Mr” or “Ms” when purchasing train tickets. If the association wins the case, private and public organisations in the 27 European Union States will have to either stop collecting gender markers when it is unnecessary or provide an option for non-binary persons in their forms.

This would be a significant step forward for the rights of non-binary persons, but also LGBTI people who do not identify within the gender binary.

The case relies on the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR), invoking the principles of data minimisation and accuracy and European non-discrimination law. It aims to set a significant precedent for the inclusion of all gender identities in the European Union, by requiring forms without any reference to gender markers or with inclusive options.

According Senior Strategic Litigation Officer with ILGA-Europe, Marie-Hélène Ludwig: “The upcoming hearing is a crucial step to put an end to the misgendering and discrimination faced by non-binary persons who are forced to choose in their day-to-day lives between two options that do not correspond to their identity.”

According to Mr Étienne Deshoulières, the lawyer representing the Mousse Association: “This procedure is not only a fight against outdated forms, but a battle for the recognition and respect of each individual in their singularity. It defends the right of every person not to be trapped in the gender binary that does not correspond to their true identity. It is a question of respect for fundamental rights to self-determination, non-discrimination and the protection of personal data.”

ILGA-Europe, alongside Transgender Europe (TGEU), are providing support to the applicants and their lawyers in this case.

European court to hear landmark case regarding discrimination against non-binary people

See also

Infringement ruling tests whether Magyar will Put pro-EU commitments into practice

Romanian court victory confirms recognition of trans identities across the EU

Poland: Supreme Administrative Court confirms EU law obligation to recognise same-sex marriages concluded abroad

Landmark CJEU ruling demands Member States to ensure legal gender recognition to guarantee freedom of movement

Q&A: Everything you want to know about the recent ruling on recognition of same-sex marriages in the EU

We welcome the EU’s Top Court landmark judgment: Member States Must Recognise Same-Sex Marriages from Other EU Countries

From Courtrooms to Parliament: Lithuania Faces a Defining Moment for Family Equality

Joint Statement: Landmark CJEU opinion demands legal gender recognition across EU

French Court orders end to mandatory gender titles on train tickets

Joint statement welcoming European court’s ruling against Poland over anti-gay hate crime

Europe, you need to catch up on providing inclusive services for non‑binary people

Semenya v. Switzerland: Grand Chamber of the European Court of Human Rights Judgment

European Court rules Czech Republic violated trans rights with forced sterilisation

Pride Ban Must Not Go Ahead as EU Advocate General Confirms Hungary’s ‘Child Protection Law’ Breaches EU Law

What the CJEU AG’s Opinion in the infringement case against Hungary means for LGBTI equality in the EU

Joint Statement: CJEU to rule on landmark case regarding ban on legal gender recognition in Bulgaria

CJEU Advocate General: Member States Must Recognise Same-Sex Marriages from Other EU Countries

Inventory of relevant SOGIESC case law and pending cases before the ECtHR and CJEU 2025

Joint statement welcoming EU’s top court judgment to correct a trans man’s gender identity data in national registry

European court rules teacher’s dismissal over gay blog violated free speech

Joint statement welcoming judgement on Russia’s failure to protect the privacy of personal data

Joint statement welcoming CJEU judgment to halt unlawful gender title collection

Joint statement on today’s long-awaited judgment from the European Court of Human Rights on violations of LGBTI human rights in Armenia

Lithuanian Court Declares anti-LGBTI law unconstitutional

Russia failed to respond adequately to politician’s homophobic verbal assault, European Court finds

Top European Court holds hearing on Polish refusal to recognise same-sex marriage certificate

Joint statement: EU Court of Justice strengthens trans rights by calling for the automatic recognition in birth certificates

Joint statement: EU Court of Justice Advocate General calls on Hungary to correct trans refugee’s gender marker in national registries

Joint statement: Trans children and young people in schools deserve safety and understanding

Joint statement on Italian Constitutional Court ruling on non-binary & trans persons’ rights