Rainbow families have the right to move and reside freely, EU court reiterates

The Court of Justice of the EU has stated that birth certificates issued in an EU country must be recognised across the EU, and that EU countries should protect the freedom of movement of rainbow families.

On June 24, the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) issued a reasoned order establishing that when an EU country has recognised two persons of the same sex as parents of a child, then the EU country of which that child is a national, should issue identity documents to that child with both parent on them, and all EU countries should protect the right to freedom of movement of the child and their family. This is a confirmation of a previous landmark judgment, that of Baby Sara.

Poland has been told that it must now provide the child known as Baby Sofia, born in 2018 to Irish and Polish mothers, with identity documents and guarantee her and her parents the right to move and reside freely in the country.

The case arose when Poland denied citizenship to baby Sofia, daughter of two mothers, Kashka, from Poland, and Sinéad, from Ireland. In 2018, Sofia was born in Spain, where the couple had gone to receive IVF treatment. Spanish authorities issued a birth certificate with the name of the two mothers but not identity documents, as children of foreigners are not automatically entitled to citizenship in the country.

At that time, in Ireland, two women could not be recognised as parents on a birth certificate. In the eyes of Irish law, the mother was the woman who gave birth to the child. As Kasha, the biological mother was not Irish, Sofia couldn’t apply for citizenship in Ireland either.

In Poland, where rainbow families are still not recognised, authorities refused to recognise Sofia’s birth certificate, depriving her of access to citizenship and identity documents. For over two years Sofia remained without any documentary proof of any nationality, and therefore at risk of statelessness. The family was could not leave Spain, as Baby Sofia couldn’t travel without documents. Her mothers had to move house every couple of months, as they were running out of savings.

Now, the CJEU has stated that an EU country is obliged to provide identity documents to a child when the child, being a national of the country, has a birth certificate issued in another member state that designates two persons of the same-sex as their parents. All EU countries must respect the documents that allow the child and their family to exercise their right to move and reside freely with the territory of the EU. These are protections granted in Articles 20 and 21 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union (TFEU) and Articles 7 and 24 of the Charter of Fundamental Rights of the EU, among others.

With this reasoned order, the CJEU has confirmed the landmark judgment delivered in the Baby Sara case last year, which arose when a same-sex couple were refused a birth certificate in Bulgaria for their daughter, also born in Spain. Poland must now provide Baby Sofia with identity documents and guarantee her and her mothers the right to move and reside freely in the country.

In the meantime, Spain issued identity documents to Sofia in March 2019. Spanish law foresees a safeguard measure that allows children born in its territory who would otherwise be stateless to acquire Spanish nationality at birth. The couple also applied for Irish citizenship for Sofia through naturalisation over two years ago, but they have not received any feedback since March 2020. The Children and Families Relationship Act, which allowed both women in a same-sex couple to be automatically recognised on their child’s birth certificate, was enforced in Ireland in May 2020.

Welcoming the order, but concerned about its implementation, the lawyer for Baby Sofia’s parents, Anna Mazurczak said: “We are, of course, happy that the Court has applied the reasoning from the Bulgarian case in a Polish case. However, the Court has not been as straightforward as we had hoped. We wanted to make sure that Poland had the obligation not only to issue an ID but also to indicate the first names of same-sex parents on it.

“Through the CJEU’s reasoned order, we hoped to convince the Supreme Administrative Court of Poland that issuing an ID with one mother’s name is not enough. The CJEU has already held that different last names contained in documents issued by different member states can cause an obstacle to the right of freedom of movement. In my opinion, the different parent names on the ID card can violate freedom of movement even more.”

Recently, a draft amendment to the Family Code was submitted for public consultation in Poland, where marriage equality, same-sex registered partnerships and co-parent recognition are not recognised. While it could improve the situation of children of same-sex parents born abroad by recognising their birth certificates, it also presents a discriminatory approach towards rainbow families. There is no clear timeline for the development and implementation of these amendments.

According Arpi Avetisyan, Head of Litigation at ILGA-Europe: “The CJEU’s reasoned order is a welcome confirmation of the rights of children in rainbow families. The Polish and Bulgarian cases that have reached the CJEU, Baby Sofia and Baby Sara, are not isolated. They show the tip of the iceberg of the numerous examples of the hardships experienced by rainbow families in the EU.

“We hope that the upcoming European Commission’s legislation on parenthood recognition, by incorporating the CJEU rulings, will provide a framework for removing obstacles to freedom of movement for rainbow families. What is crucial at the present, however, is that Poland and Bulgaria put in place necessary procedures for implementing CJEU’s judgment and reasoned order as soon as possible.”

Meanwhile, in Bulgaria, the ruling in Baby Sara’s case has not yet been implemented. While on 16 May, Sofia’s Administrative Court, which had asked the CJEU for clarification in this case, ruled that Capital Municipality, Pancharevo District must issue a birth certificate with both of Sara’s mothers on it, the decision was appealed by the Municipality on 13 June. This means that to date, Sara is still without documents and at risk of statelessness.

See also

Podcast

The Frontline: LGBTI activism: Courage to seek new strategies

This summer in Bulgaria, as two new anti-LGBTI laws were fast-tracked in advance of forthcoming elections, a cross movement effort came together to try and […]
read more
Press Release

The ILGA-Europe conference, the largest LGBTI conference in Europe and Central Asia, meets in Bucharest this weekend

The ILGA-Europe Annual Conference, the largest LGBTI conference of its kind in Europe, has brought over 400 LGBTI activists from across Europe and Central Asia […]
read more
News

Joint statement: EU Court of Justice strengthens trans rights by calling for the automatic recognition in birth certificates

ACCEPT, TGEU and ILGA-Europe welcome today’s decision of the Court of Justice of the EU (CJEU)   said that the refusal of an EU Member State […]
read more
News

Joint statement: Welcoming European Court judgement on Poland’s failure to protect same-sex couples married abroad

The European Court of Human Rights has found that Poland breached the right to respect for the family life of two same-sex Polish couples married […]
read more
News

Joint statement: EU Court of Justice Advocate General calls on Hungary to correct trans refugee’s gender marker in national registries

Háttér Society, ILGA-Europe and TGEU welcome an opinion from the Advocate General of the Court of Justice of the European Union stating that Hungarian immigration […]
read more
Blog

LGBTI activism in the new far-right era

Activists in the Balkans, Greece, Italy and Poland talk about the shared challenges across Europe as the far-right continues to gain ground. As the far-right […]
read more
News

Joint statement on Italian Constitutional Court ruling on non-binary & trans persons’ rights

ILGA-Europe and TGEU welcome a judgement of the Italian Constitutional Court finding that non-binary peoples’ rights are protected under the Italian Constitution In a judgment […]
read more
News

Latvia failed to protect human rights of victim of a homophobic attack, european Court finds

The European Court of Human rights has made a judgement in a case where the Latvian authorities declined to prosecute an anti-LGBTI attack as a […]
read more
News

Trans woman should have been allowed access to hormone therapy in prison, says European Court

The European Court of Human Rights has found that Poland violated Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights, protecting the right to private […]
read more
News

European court hears landmark case on trans rights in Hungary

The Court of Justice of the European Union held a significant hearing today concerning legal gender recognition for trans people in Hungary Today, the Court […]
read more
News

Joint statement in support of South African athlete Caster Semenya

ILGA-Europe, The International Commission of Jurists and the organisation Intersex International Europe jointly file a third-party intervention before the Grand Chamber of the European Court […]
read more
News

EU Court of Justice Advocate General calls for automatic recognition of legal gender recognition in birth certificates

In a significant development regarding the rights of trans people in the European Union, the Advocate General of the Court of Justice of the European […]
read more
News

European court to hear landmark case regarding discrimination against non-binary people

The Court of Justice of the European Union is to decide on lawsuit over the lack of provision of an option for non-binary persons, which […]
read more
Report

Inventory of relevant SOGIESC case law and pending cases before the ECtHR and CJEU

In order to focus our strategic litigation efforts across Europe to fully protect and advance LGBTI rights, with this inventory ILGA-Europe wants to support members […]
read more
Report

Our submission to the EC 2024 Rule of Law report

Over the past few years it has become increasingly clear that many government-led violations of LGBTI rights in EU Member States go hand-in-hand with an […]
read more
News

Greece adopts historic bill introducing marriage equality

We welcome and celebrate with local activists the news that the Greek parliament has adopted an historic bill introducing marriage equality, granting marriage and adoption […]
read more
Blog

Attacks on LGBTI rights in Italy are human rights violations, Commissioner reports

Since the new Italian government came into power in 2022, it has been toying with the rights of LGBTI people. Draft legislation that would do […]
read more
News

Poland must ensure that same-sex couples are legally recognised, European Court rules

The European Court of Human Rights has issued a judgement against Poland in a case taken by five same-sex couples in the country, seeking to […]
read more
News

JOINT STATEMENT ON HUMAN RIGHTS VIOLATIONS IN ITALY

Today, November 20, we celebrate UN World Children’s Day, and feel compelled to draw attention to the recent developments in Italy where some children no […]
read more
News

Significant European Court judgments in two cases concerning violence against LGBTI people involving state agents

Two successful European Court cases brought against Russia underline state obligations to protect LGBTI community from violent counter demonstrators and general hate motivated violence.
read more
News

Romania failed to protect same-sex couples, European court rules

European court has found that Romania breached the right to respect for the family life of 21 same-sex Romanian couples by failing to recognise their relationships.
read more
News

Bringing change in turbulent times: A call for applications for LGBTI groups in Poland

What is this programme about and why are we launching it? ILGA-Europe invites applications from LGBTI organisations and groups in Poland that see a concrete […]
read more
Blog

The infringement against Hungary: Behind the scenes

As the deadline for member states to decide whether they will join the European Commission’s lawsuit against Hungary for its introduction of anti-LGBTI legislation fast approaches, we look at the vital work ILGA-Europe has been doing behind the scenes to bring this case before the EU Court of Justice and to bring countries on board.
read more
Press Release

Romanian transgender man’s landmark case requesting that Romania acknowledges his UK gender recognition referred to the Court of Justice of the European Union

Arian Mirzarafie-Ahi, a transgender man with Romanian and British citizenship, has filed a first-of-its-kind lawsuit in Romania against Romanian authorities over their refusal to recognize […]
read more
Blog

For good and bad: The trending impacts on LGBTI human rights in Europe and Central Asia

The most striking finding of ILGA-Europe’s Annual Review 2023 is a stark rise in the ferocity of anti-LGBTI hate and violence reported in Europe and Central Asia. But alongside this worrying trend, there are positive developments in areas such as legal gender recognition, public support, intersex human rights and civil society. Here are the key highlights.
read more
News

Bulgaria’s Supreme Court Rejects Baby Sara’s Bulgarian Citizenship

Arguing that Baby Sara is not a Bulgarian citizen, the country’s Supreme Administrative Court (SAC) said that their decision not to grant a birth certificate […]
read more
Blog

The 5 largest attacks on the fundamental rights of LGBTI people in the EU last year

In our submission to the European Commission’s annual Rule of Law report, we’ve identified key trends in the systematic attacks on the rights of LGBTI […]
read more
Report

Our submission to the EC 2023 Rule of Law report

The submission covers developments in eight EU Member States as regards rule of law developments in the countries which have had an impact on the […]
read more
News

European Court rules against Lithuania labelling LGBTI-inclusive fairytale book harmful to children

Published in 2013 by the Lithuanian University of Educational Sciences and written by the late lesbian writer, Neringa Dangvyde Macate, the book was entitled ‘Amber […]
read more
News

After Polish Case, CJEU Rules to Protect Self-employed Workers based on Sexual Orientation

In December 2017, a self-employed worker and his partner published a music video on YouTube aimed at promoting tolerance towards same-sex couples. Shortly after the […]
read more