European Court of Justice: denying same-sex partners pension rights is unjustifiable direct discrimination
Today the European Court of Justice (ECJ) in Luxembourg delivered its judgement in a landmark case on pension rights for registered same-sex partners (case of Tadao Maruko v. Versorgungswerk der deutschen Bühnen).
The facts of the case are as follows: Mr. Maruko lived with his partner in a registered partnership. After his partner died the VddB, the pension scheme for German theatres, refused to pay him a survivor’s pension as such pensions were provided only for married partners. Mr. Maruko sued the VddB, and the Bavarian Administrative CourtMunich referred the case to the ECJ for interpretation of the 2000/78/EC Directive which established a general framework for equal treatment in employment and occupation.
The ECJ ruled that the refusal to grant the survivor’s pension to life partners constitutes direct discrimination on grounds of sexual orientation, when the surviving spouses and surviving life partners are in a comparable situation as regards that pension. And the ECJ made clear that the criterion for such a comparable situation is whether the partners “live in a union of mutual support and assistance which is formally constituted for life” (par. 67). A criterion which is fulfilled by the German legislation (par. 62, 67-69).
Dr Helmut Graupner represented ILGA-Europe in this case before the ECJ.
Patricia Prendiville, Executive Director of ILGA-Europe, said:
“We welcome today’s ruling of the European Court of Justice and its strong wording which unequivocally stated that ‘refusal to grant the survivor’s pension to life partners constitutes direct discrimination on grounds of sexual orientation’ and therefore it cannot be justified in any circumstance.
ILGA-Europe celebrates this significant achievement which means that it will be applicable in all EU countries which provide formal registration of same-sex unions and require mutual maintenance.
At the same time ILGA-Europe is concerned that this decision does not have immediate legal consequences for same-sex partners in those EU countries that do not yet recognise same-sex unions. This creates a discriminatory two-tier level of protection for lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender (LGBT) EU nationals who are divided into two categories as their access to survivor pension rights depends on their country of residence. ILGA-Europe looks forward to seeing how the EU is going to eliminate this discriminatory divide based on nationality and/or place of residence of LGBT people.”
For more information please contact
Juris Lavrikovs at + 32 2 609 54 16 / + 32 496 708 375
Notes for editors:
(1) ILGA-Europe is the European Region of the International Lesbian and Gay Association and works for equality and human rights for lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender people in Europe.
(2) Text of the ECJ’s press release is available on ECJ’s website: http://curia.europa.eu/en/actu/communiques/cp08/aff/cp080017en.pdf
(3) Full judgement is available on ECJ’s website: http://curia.europa.eu/jurisp/cgi-bin/form.pl?lang=EN&Submit=rechercher&...
(4) Website of Dr Helmut Graupner, who represented ILGA-Europe in this case before the ECJ: www.graupner.at